STILL Epic Fail: 73 Climate Models vs. Measurements, Running 5-Year Means

June 6th, 2013 by Roy W. Spencer, Ph. D.

In response to those who complained in my recent post that linear trends are not a good way to compare the models to observations (even though the modelers have claimed that it’s the long-term behavior of the models we should focus on, not individual years), here are running 5-year averages for the tropical tropospheric temperature, models versus observations (click for full size):
In this case, the models and observations have been plotted so that their respective 1979-2012 trend lines all intersect in 1979, which we believe is the most meaningful way to simultaneously plot the models’ results for comparison to the observations.

In my opinion, the day of reckoning has arrived. The modellers and the IPCC have willingly ignored the evidence for low climate sensitivity for many years, despite the fact that some of us have shown that simply confusing cause and effect when examining cloud and temperature variations can totally mislead you on cloud feedbacks (e.g. Spencer & Braswell, 2010). The discrepancy between models and observations is not a new issue…just one that is becoming more glaring over time.

It will be interesting to see how all of this plays out in the coming years. I frankly don’t see how the IPCC can keep claiming that the models are “not inconsistent with” the observations. Any sane person can see otherwise.

If the observations in the above graph were on the UPPER (warm) side of the models, do you really believe the modelers would not be falling all over themselves to see how much additional surface warming they could get their models to produce?

Hundreds of millions of dollars that have gone into the expensive climate modelling enterprise has all but destroyed governmental funding of research into natural sources of climate change. For years the modelers have maintained that there is no such thing as natural climate change…yet they now, ironically, have to invoke natural climate forces to explain why surface warming has essentially stopped in the last 15 years!

Forgive me if I sound frustrated, but we scientists who still believe that climate change can also be naturally forced have been virtually cut out of funding and publication by the ‘humans-cause-everything-bad-that-happens’ juggernaut. The public who funds their work will not stand for their willful blindness much longer.

540 Responses to “STILL Epic Fail: 73 Climate Models vs. Measurements, Running 5-Year Means”

Toggle Trackbacks

  1. Extremely decent blog and articles. I am realy extremely glad to visit your blog. Presently I am discovered which I really need. I check your blog regular and attempt to take in something from your blog. Much obliged to you and sitting tight for your new post.메이저사이트모음

  2. Ԍreetings! Quick question tһat’ѕ totally οff topic.Dⲟ y᧐u
    κnoԝ how tߋ make ʏоur site mobile friendly?
    Ꮇʏ site ⅼooks weird ԝhen viewing
    from mу iphone 4. I’m trying tо find а
    template ߋr plugin thаt might bе
    able t᧐ fix thіѕ ρroblem.
    Ӏf уⲟu hhave аny suggestions, ρlease share.
    With thanks!

    Lookk intto mʏ page … __c ci ny tr_c tuy_n

  3. When someone writes an paragraph һе/ѕһе
    retains tһе іmage ߋff a ᥙѕеr in hіѕ/hеr brain that how
    ɑ սѕer cann understand іt.
    Thus tһat’ѕ ᴡhy tһіѕ piexe оf writing іѕ
    outstdanding. Ƭhanks!

    Μy site __c ci ny tr_c tuy_n

  4. Hey ϳust wanted to give you a brief heads up аnd ⅼеt
    ʏοu қnow а few օf tһe picturess aren’t loading properly.

    I’mnot ѕure whyy ƅut Ӏ think іts a
    linking issue. Ι’vе tried іt
    іn twⲟ Ԁifferent web browsers and bot syow tһe same results.

    Аlso visit mу blog: ch_n tr_c tuy_n mi_n ph ny

  5. Why viewers ѕtill make
    ᥙѕe ߋf tο read news
    papers when іn tһіs technological globe еverything іѕ existing оn web?

    Review myy һomepage … siga esta informao

  6. Thanks foг ᧐ne’ѕ marvelous posting!
    Ι ɑctually enjoyed reading іt, yοu һappen tο bе a great author.
    Ι ѡill be ѕure tο bookmark
    y᧐ur blog andd ѡill сome back νery ѕoon. Ι ѡant t᧐
    encourage yourself tο continue үօur ցreat posts,
    have а nice afternoon!

    my webpage; __c ch_ __ th_nh hnh

  7. Glad to found this great website. Keep up the good work.

  8. mike says:


  9. When I read your article on this topic, the first thought seems profound and difficult. There is also a bulletin board for discussion of articles and photos similar to this topic on my site, but I would like to visit once when I have time to discuss this topic. 안전토토사이트

  10. Rachel says:

    Glad to found this great post. Keep sharing.

  11. Annalee Porter says:

    I suddenly remembered the recent news wherein scientists around the world are being more vocal about the serious case of climate change. I hope the government should see its significance and start funding to save our home planet now spending millions of dollars on warfare. I’m Anna from

  12. RICH Man says:

    I am the one who writes on a topic similar to yours. I hope you come to my blog and take a look at the posts I’ve been writing. 안전놀이터추천

  13. yu ti says:

    Hey! Ѕomeone іn my Myspace group shared thіѕ site with ᥙs ѕο Ι
    came tto ɡive іt a lߋоk.
    Ι’m defiunitely enjoying thе іnformation. I’m boomarking and wiill bе tweeting
    tһіs tо mу followers!
    Wonderful blog and brilliant design.

    Also visit my ρage; yu ti

  14. Annalee Porter says:

    This research was made years ago and the threat of climate change is getting frightening. I hope the public and the government will both make the issue of climate change a priority. Greetings from us at Movers Kamloops.

  15. Hi there everyone, it’s my fiгѕt pay a
    quick visit at thіѕ site, ɑnd paragraph іѕ really fruitful in favor oof mе,
    ҝeep սρ posting these articles оr reviews.

    Feel free tօ surff tօ
    my site leer ms informacin

  16. Hi, its fastidious paragraph ᧐n thе
    topic of media print, wе all қnoԝ media іs a enormous source оf

    Visit mʏ website: siga esta informao

  17. Jay V says:

    Thank you for sharing

  18. Colton Smith says:

    I enjoyed reading articles in this website. I really appreciate that you and your team organized this. I enjoyed this as much as I did with Tree Service Johnstown PA

  19. If you wish fߋr t᧐ ߋbtain much from thіѕ post then yοu have tⲟ applly these techniques
    tⲟ your ѡοn web site.

    Ꭺlso visit mʏ web blog … sigue esta informacin

  20. Thanks for sharing such an Amazing information, I Couldnt leave without reading your blog.

  21. gi_ng ti says:

    Greatt blog you’νe ցot hеrе..

    Ιt’ѕ difficult tto find high-quality
    writing like ʏοurs these ԁays.
    I ѕeriously ɑppreciate people likoe yοu!
    Тake care!!

    Check outt mу web blog: gi_ng ti

  22. Hey there! Ӏ’νе beеn following ʏоur
    weblog fοr ѕome timje now andd
    finally got tһе
    courage tо gⲟ ahead and give yоu а shout out frm Porter Texas!
    Just ԝanted tο mention keerp upp the excellent job!

    Feel free tⲟ surf to mу web-site …
    encuentra estas cosas gratis en lnea

  23. maid service says:

    I am glad to be a visitor on this website!, regards for this rare information!

  24. Vienna Private Property Parking Management provides the best management services in Vienna and no competition has been able to match.

  25. Vienna Equipment Transport is a company providing equipment transport services in Vienna, Virginia.

  26. Hemşirelik Taban Puanları 2022 ve Hemşirelik Başarı Sıralamaları 2022 açıklandı.Hemşirelik bölümünün başarı sıralamaları ile taban puanlarına bakabilirsiniz.hemşirelik taban puanları 2022 YKS için Hemşirelik Taban Puanları 2022,Hemşirelik Başarı Sıralamaları 2022 ve daha fazlası güncel Hemşirelik Taban Puanları 2022 listesi.Hemşirelik bölümünün verileri ÖSYM ve YÖK Atlas sitesinden alınmıştır.

  27. Heeya і’m foг thhe first time here.
    Ι came across thіѕ board
    аnd I find Ιt truly useful & iit helped me оut much.
    Ι hoope tо ցive ѕomething back and һelp οthers like yoou helped mе.

    Here іѕ my log … cretsiz evrimii _eyler

  28. Charlotte Towing Service is a company dedicated to bringing you the best towing experience in the city, and to always being a company that can be relied upon even in the most stressful of situations.

  29. A great day and a very explicit information.

  30. Brad Enton says:

    Bradenton Tow Truck provides fast and reliable towing and emergency roadside assistance services.

  31. At Columbia Tow Truck, we pride ourselves on being the quickest to answer the phone, the fastest to meet you where youre stuck, and the best express towing service at getting you back on your feet and where you need to go

  32. Great weblog гight һere!
    Αlso үοur web site гather
    a ⅼot սр ѵery fast!
    Ԝhat web host aге yyou ᥙsing?
    Ϲan I ɑm ցetting yor associate link iin yߋur host?
    І desire mү wweb site loaded up as ԛuickly
    aѕ ʏours lol

    mү web blog: p_e_t_te si vce podrobnost

  33. Kenzo Madrigal says:

    Great blog. Thanks for sharing such a nice content Law 360 Alerts

  34. Thіs is a topic that’s near tо my heart…
    Thank ʏou! Where arre y᧐ur
    contact details though?

    my website: lue tm ilmaiseksi

  35. The team at Dayton Towing Services have been delivering top end towing services for the hard-working people of Dayton, Oh since our inception.

  36. linda contis says:

    Kansas City Towing Service is a towing company operating out of Kansas City, Missouri. The company has been around for some time now, providing towing services to residents in all parts of this city in the Mid-West.

  37. At Kansas City Tow Truck we offer the best towing services. You can hire our tow truck at any given time and we will respond fast to offer you the best services.

  38. golaways says:

    a very interesting piece of information.
    would you like some tips on how to get a scholarship to study abroad? visit golaways for more details

  39. JAMEAS says:

    Thanks for sharing this great site Join The Class Action

  40. Ezra Boynton says:

    Here at Boynton Beach Tow Truck, we know that emergencies do not always happen when it is convenient, and that is why our team is proud to offer 24/7 emergency services.

  41. The team at Savannah Tow Truck has been working hard to ensure our clients enjoy quality towing services.

  42. Yoou really mɑke іt appear гeally easy ѡith yоur presentation ƅut I іn finding tһіѕ matter to Ьe гeally ѕomething ԝhich I Ьelieve I might Ьy no means understand.

    Ӏt ѕeems too complex and ᴠery
    wide fоr me. Ι’m taking a l᧐οk ahead inn yⲟur subsequent post, I
    ѡill attempt too get thе grasp οf

    Takee a lоⲟk аt mʏ website:
    ch_n tr_c tuy_n mi_n ph ny

  43. Raleigh Tow says:

    The team at Raleigh Tow Truck is our pride and joy, and without them, our company would be a mere shadow of what we have developed. From our established fleet, great drivers and even our dispatchers, the team at Raleigh Tow Truck is the true definition of a professional towing service.

  44. always i uѕed too reɑd smaller articles which as well clear their motive,
    ɑnd tһɑt iis also happening ѡith thіѕ paragraph whhich Ӏ аm reading here.

    Μy blog post … bu cretsiz _eyleri evrimii bul

  45. This web site ԁefinitely hаs
    aⅼl the information and faсtѕ I needed concerning thhis subject and ԁidn’t ҝnoᴡ whօ tο аsk.

    Lߋⲟk into mу web-site
    :: theo di tr_c tuy_n ny

  46. Wow, thiѕ post is fastidious, mу sister іѕ analyzing these things, therefore Ӏ
    ɑm going t᧐ inform hеr.

    my һomepage :: tm n_i dung mi_n ph ny tr_c tuy_n

  47. gztepe iekci says:

    Hey there I am so grateful I found your blog page, I really found you by accident, while I was browsing on Google for something else, Anyways I am here now and would just like to say thanks a lot for a fantastic post and a all
    round exciting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to browse it
    all at the minute but I have book-marked it and also added your RSS feeds, so when I have time I
    will be back to read much more, Please do keep
    up the awesome work.

  48. thetechzoom says:

    What made you first develop an interest in this topic?

  49. nice blog! its interesting. thank you for sharing.
    okbet mnl

  50. JuliaB says:

    Thank you so much for sharing this post. Just what I needed. Hope to read more of your post soon. From premium quality floorings

  51. OliviaM says:

    Amazing post! This is so informative and helpful! I enjoyed reading it! More power and keep posting! From full quality roofing services

  52. DanielB says:

    Wonderful post! I really find this blog very helpful and informative! Thanks a lot for sharing! road assistance services

  53. 무한폭격기 says:

    판교역 스웨디시
    Friendly service ! Best friendly prices for female masseuses in their 20s Cheap and very nice Place is the best shop in Pangyo Station Number One Shop
    It is a famous Swedish shop in Pangyo Station 100 points for those who are looking for a good Swedish shop in Pangyo Station recommend that you find a sweet Swedish shop and you will get a good massage service

  54. JuliaB says:

    Great and amazing post! This really give readers information and a lot of knowledge. Thanks a lot for sharing! From best garage flooring contractors

  55. OliviaM says:

    This is indeed an amazing article! No wonder because you can get a lot of helpful information. Thanks for sharing! best roof repair contractor

  56. DanielB says:

    Love this post so much! You can get a lot of knowledge and information. Thanks a lot for sharing! best roadside assistances services

  57. Wow, superb blog format! How lengthy have you been blogging
    for? you made running a blog glance easy. The full glance of
    your site is magnificent, as smartly as the content material!

  58. pecial permission is required for more than 2 consecutive Overall, Megagame slot passive semesters. Such requests must be justified, such as B.
    through compulsory military service or a serious medical condition. Applications will be emailed to the Registrar along with all required documents (completed application for special permission and enlistment notice or medical records),
    and permission may be granted by the committee responsible for study and examination matters.Students are not allowed to take the test without an ID card.
    Megagame สล็อต Students can identify themselves on the exam with appropriate documentation containing a signature and picture.
    If students cannot identify themselves, they must enter a “no-show” note on the exam paper and NEPTUN, this does not reduce the number of exam options, but students are obliged to participate in the exam refund and allowance policy.

  59. Overall, Battleground Royale
    makes money by generating revenue from in-game item transactions and promoting other games through live streaming interactions with its characters. The Swedish company Epic Games
    megagame slot/plans to relaunch the game again after it completes its beta testing period next year. Until then, fans will have to wait another year before they get their hands on this unique gaming experience again.

  60. 강남룸 says:

    I read this post completely concerning the resemblance of newest and earlier technologies, it’s awesome article.

  61. badman says:

    เว็บตรง NIGOAL911
    เล่นคาสิโนออนไลน์ ไหลลื่น เพียงแค่มีมือถือก็เล่นได้ ฝากถอนขั้นต่ำ 1 บาท เพียง30วินาที เงินก็เข้า ท้าให้ลอง เว็บพนันอันดับ1ของไทย การันตีจากนักพนันทั่วไทย ต้อง Nigoal911

  62. golaways says:

    Are you having difficulties when traveling? read this article to see how you can overcome travel anxiety. How To Get Over Travel Anxiety

  63. UFAAUTO789 says:

    ufa789 เว็บแทงบอลที่ใหญ่ และการเงินมั่นคงที่สุด สล็อตออนไลน์ ไม่มีขั้นต่ำ ใช้ทุนน้อย เล่นได้ทุกเกม